Ask most brokerage owners how they set their desk fee and the honest answer is split. Is it based on the value the office delivers, or on covering overhead?
The pressure behind that question is real. The agent pool is shrinking, transaction volume is down, and when a producing agent sits across the table and the fee comes up, most owners are scared to lose them over price. So they do what feels safe: free months, marketing money, sometimes a free office.
Sit in the owner’s chair, then the agent’s. An agent tells a client they cut their commission, then paid for the lawyer and the staging, all to win one listing. My first thought is that they’re struggling and need better training to build their confidence and true value. They’re racing themselves to the bottom, a race they’re guaranteed to lose.
Now look at the brokerage version. Free months, marketing money, a free office. Same move, different chair.
Some incentives are par for the industry, and I get it. But there’s a limit, and once an office crosses it, momentum starts building in the wrong direction. It feels good in the moment. It isn’t a long-term strategy for prosperity. And an agent who signs for an incentive can be poached for the same. That owner didn’t recruit a producing agent. They rented one.
Here’s the truth underneath it: fees are only an issue in the absence of value. It’s not an agent’s problem that an owner’s overhead needs feeding, just as it’s not a seller’s fault when an agent needs 6% because they aren’t making money. There is a path to prosperity in this business, and it runs through developing the ACTUAL value an office says it has.
So what does a top producer get from an office that they can’t get down the street? They weigh five things:
Speed of support
Friction in their transactions
The chance to build authority in the market
How achievement gets recognized
The network they get close to
Offices that can’t answer clearly eventually hear the question: why partner here when the same services cost half the price down the street? By the time a producer asks that, they’ve usually seen the owner’s entire hand.
I built a one-page worksheet called “Can You Justify Your Fee?” that scores an office on all five in about 10 minutes.
It’s free to download below just click on the image.
Reply and tell me which score surprised you.
I'm Sean Lowry, founder of Skyglass Private Consulting. I've sold real estate, managed it, and been named REMAX Canada's Manager of the Year (2024), all in over 10 years in the business. I've worked with some of the largest brokerages in the industry. Today, I write about how brokerage owners and managers can build an office worth the fee, and why the agents still closing deals are the only headcount worth chasing.